Feminist History
Did I Leave the Left or Did the Left Leave Me?
Twenty years ago, I knew
who my friends were. Long hair, tye-dyes and bell bottoms were our uniform.
I also knew that what we all believed in was right: freedom, peace,
love, compassion, and life.
We fought against the war
in Vietnam because it was killing our brothers and sisters and their
children. We demonstrated against CIA actions in Central and South America
because we thought that "Kill a Commie for Christ" was just a tad misconceived.
We stood side by side with our African-American brothers and sisters
because Klansmen, Nazis, and all-American bigots were killing them for
kicks. We marched for women's rights and the ERA.
We still fight to end the
torture of animals in laboratories, the abuses heaped on helpless farm
animals, the animals caught in traps and the fur-farm victims who are
skinned alive to satisfy the vanity of the obscenely rich.
Over these two decades we
have had many causes, struggles, battles. All of them to preserve the
ideals we knew were right. And we were as one. We loved life and would
fight forever to protect its sanctity.
But today something is wrong.
I look around me at the animals rights demonstrations, at the vigils
against the death penalty, at the Earth Day celebration, and the anti-apartheid
rallies. All of these people who are my family in the struggle for life
are against me. I cannot speak to my friends about THE ISSUE.
When did I lose my sanity?
When did my world become so distorted that I stopped seeing the truth?
How can I not know that true compassion is saving whales, dolphins,
dogs, mice, minks, South Americans, Brazilian rain forests and even
convicted murderers but not an unborn baby?
And how did it happen that
these right-wing, fascist, capitalist, imperialist, industrial-military
exploiters of everything that lives can feel the same as I do about
abortion?
In Buddhism there is a meditation
which aims at achieving mental equanimity, the viewing of all sentient
beings in the exact same light. In it, the meditator visualizes an enemy,
a friend and an acquaintance about whom s/he has no feelings. The meditator
thinks of why s/he has certain feelings about each, then remembering
that each of the three has been in a different relationship with the
meditator in previous lives, reverses the feelings about each, visualizing
the friend as the enemy and the enemy as the friend.
Somehow this meditation has
become reality. I am joined with those I distrust most and alienated
from those I love. The result of this, the end product of my respect
for all life as sacred and equal is my complete isolation. I could have
friends among the "left" but we could never agree about abortion. I
could have friends in the "pro-life" camp but their idea of life seems
too selective.
So I remain alone, wondering
who can explain this all to me? Who can clear up this mystery? Is it
not hypocrisy to call one's self pro-life but support wars and the death
penalty, ignore starvation, use products tested on animals, eat meat,
wear leather? Is it not hypocrisy to scream and yell to save every life
but one's own unborn child, especially when one admits one can't be
sure it is not life?
Somehow it seems that, if
we have dedicated our lives to fighting for the rights of the unprotected,
that we must fight on for the protection of the most vulnerable of all
life. If we are wrong in seeking to protect that life, the end result
will only be more babies born. However, if they are wrong and the slaughter
continues, they will have murdered their own children and helped others
do the same. Is this not cause for tears?
Elliot Klein
Reprinted from SisterLife